A endangered American marten killed in a fisher trap in Ferdinand, 2023.

 

Since 2004, Vermont trappers have been responsible for capturing and killing dozens of endangered American marten, despite their classification as a “High Priority Species of Greatest Conservation Need” by the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department (VFWD) in the 2015, and 2025 Wildlife Action Plans. One of the goals outlined in that plan is to “Assess the effectiveness and practicality of various trap configurations and trapping techniques for minimizing the incidental take of marten.” Yet marten continue to die in lethal body-gripping traps set for fisher in the few small areas of Vermont where the species is struggling to survive.

 

 

For years, the VFWD and trappers have argued that killing fisher in marten recovery areas benefits the smaller endangered mustelids, as it removes competition by the larger fisher which sometimes preys on marten, but as recently as 2025, marten also continue to be caught in the same traps set for fisher. At the August 19, 2026 Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board (VFWB) meeting in Montpelier, VFWD furbearer biologist Brehan Furfey argued in favor of asking state legislators to legalize baited body-gripping traps that were outlawed in 2024. Back then, VFWD claimed that the new trapping rules would “establish standards for trap types and use of baits to reduce the risk of catching pets and non-target wildlife.” But at the August meeting, Furfey stated that the new rules have, “hindered the ability of trappers to trap fisher effectively.”

 

Highlights indicate rule changes sought by trappers and VFWD

 

Currently, only baited body-gripping traps larger than 40 square inches and smaller than 60 square inches are allowed on land.

 

Both the VFWD, and Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board Chairman Paul Noel have provided no scientific evidence for their desire to legalize smaller baited body-gripping traps as a means to reduce the incidental take of non-target wildlife. Instead, at the July 29, 2026 VFWB meeting, Chair Noel said the new rules have, “been a hardship for trappers for the last two years.” Because of the proposed rule change, Vermont Wildlife Patrol (VWP) petitioned the Board on October 14, 2026 to restrict fisher trapping in the areas where at least 46 marten have been killed by fisher trappers, providing detailed records obtained through a public records request that reveal that a handful of trappers have repeatedly caught and killed fisher without being required to modify their traps or remove traps once an endangered species take has occurred.  In December 2012, the then President of the Vermont Trappers Association himself killed three marten. Between 2009 and 2016, another individual fisher trapper killed six marten, four within one week of the December fisher trapping season. Again in 2012, one trapper killed three marten in the Victory Wildlife Management Area. The last two recorded incidental takes of marten in fisher traps, in 2023 and 2025, were by the same trapper who was allowed to simply remove the dead endangered species and reset his traps in the same location.

6 Incidental Marten Deaths, Same Fisher Trapper, Same Areas:

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1aDMoW7CZJlrl5NEcr8Ieu_Cp3yi_5tMH?usp=sharing

2015 VFWD Email Regarding Incidental Marten Takes Not Being Reported by Wardens

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1__zdprUf7JoOiV0n905iYepg7ilbEm0X/view?usp=sharing

 

In 2025 this fisher trapper was allowed to continue trapping in the same location he had already killed an endangered marten with a possibly illegal trap.

 

These documented cases are contrary to statements made by furbearer biologist Furfey at the August VFWB meeting when questioned by Grand Isle County Board member Beth Deimling about marten incidental takes. “Trappers know to avoid areas, I should say, that have marten, and we work pretty closely, I know wardens work very closely with trappers to help avoid any sort of incidental take of marten.” Yet evidence obtained from VFWD’s own records and Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s field investigations tell a very different story. In Ferdinand, Vermont where more marten have been killed by fisher trappers than any other area in the state, VFWD warden Randy Hazard was himself filmed baiting and checking his own fisher traps in uniform and with his official state vehicle. Hazard is the primary warden responsible for the reporting of incidental marten takes and his name appears on reports dating back to December 2016 when he reported four marten killed by the same fisher trapper in just five days of the month-long fisher trapping season.

 

VFWD email detailing multiple marten takes by same trappers during 2012 fisher season.

 

Vermont’s fisher trappers, including warden Hazard, do not avoid areas with endangered marten. Instead they continue to set body-gripping traps in Ferdinand and surrounding towns where marten have been dying in fisher traps since 2004. In his most recent report of an incidental take of a marten in Ferdinand in 2025, he states, “I patrolled the area where (redacted) told me he had caught the marten. I found and checked a total of 19 fisher sets and found they were in compliance with both the statewide trapping regulations for body grip traps and the special WMU E regulations in Appendix 4.” Vermont Wildlife Patrol reported Hazard to the Vermont Criminal Justice Council which determined no evidence of wrongdoing.

Links to 2023 & 2025 Warden Reports on Incidental Marten Takes on South America Pond Rd., Ferdinand:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1htGJVUbysOoM5mB9z36KE49_TnJx93J8/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Tjqb_lKyDDCyy8fKpfN7ZOzxh-ZhsD-V/view?usp=sharing

Recorded Incidental Marten Captures 2004-2025

 

After reviewing records on marten takes during Vermont’s December fisher trapping season, Vermont Wildlife Patrol conducted an investigation to determine whether fisher trapping was still occurring along South America Pond Road, where multiple marten takes have been reported. Many fisher trappers leave their cage sets attached to trees year around, minus the body-gripping traps, so it was possible to locate fisher trap sites that are used later in December. Our survey found 8 trap sites, all in the immediate vicinity of past incidental marten take locations, revealing that fisher trappers are still setting traps where marten have been killed before. Sadly, VFWD wardens are clearly not advising trappers to avoid these areas.

 

 

Six of the eight fisher trap sites documented by VWP in September 2026, along South America Pond Road in Ferdinand.

 

On December 16, 2026 the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board will reconvene to discuss and possibly vote on multiple petitions, including VWP’s marten petition, as well as whether to open the furbearer rule making process to allow baited body-gripping traps smaller than 40 square inches. If the Board votes to allow the smaller traps, their decision will then be open to public comments. After which, any rule changes must also be approved by legislative committees that we hope will have many questions about why the changes are necessary so soon after the current rules were approved in 2024. The VFWD seems unwilling to ask for anything Vermont’s trappers are opposed too, and any willingness to modify trapping practices for the sake of marten recovery has only been met with resistance by Vermont’s tight knit trapping community. Please contact your county representative to the Fish and Wildlife Board and remind them that their responsibility is to best manage our state’s wildlife not for any one special interest group, but for the sake of all species that also call Vermont home.

 

 

ASK YOUR COUNTY REPRESENTATIVE TO SUPPORT THE AMERICAN MARTEN PETITION: 

 

Hannah Johnson Caledonia County: ANR.FWBoardCaledonia@vermont.gov

Richard Craig Lamoille County: ANR.FWBoardLamoille@vermont.gov

Robert Patterson Addison County: ANR.FWBoardAddison@vermont.gov

Ryan Kilborn Orange County: ANR.FWBoardOrange@vermont.gov

Neal Hogan Bennington County: ANR.FWBoardBennington@vermont.gov

Paul Noel (Chair) Orleans County: ANR.FWBoardOrleans@vermont.gov

Heather Furman Chittenden County: ANR.FWBoardChittenden@vermont.gov

Martin Van Buren Rutland County: ANR.FWBoardRutland@vermont.gov

Christopher Masson Essex County: ANR.FWBoardEssex@vermont.gov

Jon Valsangiacomo Washington County: ANR.FWBoardWashington@vermont.gov

Jeffrey Corey Franklin County: ANR.FWBoardFranklin@vermont.gov

David Deen Windham County: ANR.FWBoardWindham@vermont.gov

Beth Deimling Grand Isle County: ANR.FWBoardGrandIsle@vermont.gov

Nicholas Burnham Windsor County: ANR.FWBoardWindsor@vermont.gov



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>