A endangered American marten killed in a fisher trap in Ferdinand, 2023.
Since 2004, Vermont trappers have been responsible for capturing and killing dozens of endangered American marten, despite their classification as a “High Priority Species of Greatest Conservation Need” by the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department (VFWD) in the 2015, and 2025 Wildlife Action Plans. One of the goals outlined in that plan is to “Assess the effectiveness and practicality of various trap configurations and trapping techniques for minimizing the incidental take of marten.” Yet marten continue to die in lethal body-gripping traps set for fisher in the few small areas of Vermont where the species is struggling to survive.
For years, the VFWD and trappers have argued that killing fisher in marten recovery areas benefits the smaller endangered mustelids, as it removes competition by the larger fisher which sometimes preys on marten, but as recently as 2025, marten also continue to be caught in the same traps set for fisher. At the August 19, 2026 Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board (VFWB) meeting in Montpelier, VFWD furbearer biologist Brehan Furfey argued in favor of asking state legislators to legalize baited body-gripping traps that were outlawed in 2024. Back then, VFWD claimed that the new trapping rules would “establish standards for trap types and use of baits to reduce the risk of catching pets and non-target wildlife.” But at the August meeting, Furfey stated that the new rules have, “hindered the ability of trappers to trap fisher effectively.”
Highlights indicate rule changes sought by trappers and VFWD
Currently, only baited body-gripping traps larger than 40 square inches and smaller than 60 square inches are allowed on land.
Both the VFWD, and Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board Chairman Paul Noel have provided no scientific evidence for their desire to legalize smaller baited body-gripping traps as a means to reduce the incidental take of non-target wildlife. Instead, at the July 29, 2026 VFWB meeting, Chair Noel said the new rules have, “been a hardship for trappers for the last two years.” Because of the proposed rule change, Vermont Wildlife Patrol (VWP) petitioned the Board on October 14, 2026 to restrict fisher trapping in the areas where at least 46 marten have been killed by fisher trappers, providing detailed records obtained through a public records request that reveal that a handful of trappers have repeatedly caught and killed fisher without being required to modify their traps or remove traps once an endangered species take has occurred. In December 2012, the then President of the Vermont Trappers Association himself killed three marten. Between 2009 and 2016, another individual fisher trapper killed six marten, four within one week of the December fisher trapping season. Again in 2012, one trapper killed three marten in the Victory Wildlife Management Area. The last two recorded incidental takes of marten in fisher traps, in 2023 and 2025, were by the same trapper who was allowed to simply remove the dead endangered species and reset his traps in the same location.
6 Incidental Marten Deaths, Same Fisher Trapper, Same Areas:
In 2025 this fisher trapper was allowed to continue trapping in the same location he had already killed an endangered marten with a possibly illegal trap.
These documented cases are contrary to statements made by furbearer biologist Furfey at the August VFWB meeting when questioned by Grand Isle County Board member Beth Deimling about marten incidental takes. “Trappers know to avoid areas, I should say, that have marten, and we work pretty closely, I know wardens work very closely with trappers to help avoid any sort of incidental take of marten.” Yet evidence obtained from VFWD’s own records and Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s field investigations tell a very different story. In Ferdinand, Vermont where more marten have been killed by fisher trappers than any other area in the state, VFWD warden Randy Hazard was himself filmed baiting and checking his own fisher traps in uniform and with his official state vehicle. Hazard is the primary warden responsible for the reporting of incidental marten takes and his name appears on reports dating back to December 2016 when he reported four marten killed by the same fisher trapper in just five days of the month-long fisher trapping season.
VFWD email detailing multiple marten takes by same trappers during 2012 fisher season.
Vermont’s fisher trappers, including warden Hazard, do not avoid areas with endangered marten. Instead they continue to set body-gripping traps in Ferdinand and surrounding towns where marten have been dying in fisher traps since 2004. In his most recent report of an incidental take of a marten in Ferdinand in 2025, he states, “I patrolled the area where (redacted) told me he had caught the marten. I found and checked a total of 19 fisher sets and found they were in compliance with both the statewide trapping regulations for body grip traps and the special WMU E regulations in Appendix 4.” Vermont Wildlife Patrol reported Hazard to the Vermont Criminal Justice Council which determined no evidence of wrongdoing.
Links to 2023 & 2025 Warden Reports on Incidental Marten Takes on South America Pond Rd., Ferdinand:
After reviewing records on marten takes during Vermont’s December fisher trapping season, Vermont Wildlife Patrol conducted an investigation to determine whether fisher trapping was still occurring along South America Pond Road, where multiple marten takes have been reported. Many fisher trappers leave their cage sets attached to trees year around, minus the body-gripping traps, so it was possible to locate fisher trap sites that are used later in December. Our survey found 8 trap sites, all in the immediate vicinity of past incidental marten take locations, revealing that fisher trappers are still setting traps where marten have been killed before. Sadly, VFWD wardens are clearly not advising trappers to avoid these areas.
Six of the eight fisher trap sites documented by VWP in September 2026, along South America Pond Road in Ferdinand.
On December 16, 2026 the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board will reconvene to discuss and possibly vote on multiple petitions, including VWP’s marten petition, as well as whether to open the furbearer rule making process to allow baited body-gripping traps smaller than 40 square inches. If the Board votes to allow the smaller traps, their decision will then be open to public comments. After which, any rule changes must also be approved by legislative committees that we hope will have many questions about why the changes are necessary so soon after the current rules were approved in 2024. The VFWD seems unwilling to ask for anything Vermont’s trappers are opposed too, and any willingness to modify trapping practices for the sake of marten recovery has only been met with resistance by Vermont’s tight knit trapping community. Please contact your county representative to the Fish and Wildlife Board and remind them that their responsibility is to best manage our state’s wildlife not for any one special interest group, but for the sake of all species that also call Vermont home.
ASK YOUR COUNTY REPRESENTATIVE TO SUPPORT THE AMERICAN MARTEN PETITION:
Hannah Johnson Caledonia County: ANR.FWBoardCaledonia@vermont.gov
Richard Craig Lamoille County: ANR.FWBoardLamoille@vermont.gov
Since the 1970’s Wisconsin’s Department of Natural Resources (WDNR) has been reintroducing American marten in northern Wisconsin, where like Vermont, the small member of the weasel family was extirpated in the 1800’s due to over trapping and habitat destruction. The American marten is Wisconsin’s only endangered species, and recovery efforts are driven by a partnership between WDNR, Tribal governments and the Wisconsin Trappers Association. Three localized regions of the marten’s traditional range have been designated Marten Restoration Areas, where traps known to capture marten “incidentally” are prohibited and trappers are required to use non-lethal trapping methods, or make modifications to traps to minimize the incidental take of the endangered species.
From the Management and Conservation Plan for Marten in Wisconsin
On October 14, 2026 Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s (VWP) state director, Rod Coronado presented a petition to the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board (VFWB) requesting similar restrictions to Wisconsin’s in Vermont’s own American marten recovery areas. The American marten also has state endangered species status and the 2025 Vermont Wildlife Action Plan ranks marten as a high priority species of greatest conservation need. VWP’s petition was in response to a recent proposal by the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board to legalize smaller baited body-gripping traps that were prohibited in 2024, when the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department (VFWD) was directed by Act 159 to modernize trapping regulations to improve animal welfare and reduce the incidental take of domestic pets and non-target wildlife.
At a July 2026 VFWB meeting, Chair Paul Noel stated, “When that rule [furbearer] did get passed, there was an error in the final ruling that we all missed. You can call it a typo, a clerical error, an administrative error. I’ll get into it in more detail another time, but it involves the use of baited body grip on land. There was an error in the size of trap that could be used in that scenario. So I’m going to get this on the agenda for next month and know we can get into it more deeply then, but it’s going to involve opening up the trapping rules to fix this error. It’s been a hardship for trappers for the last two years.”
The baited body-gripping traps Noel refers to are those preferred by trappers targeting fisher. Since 2004, there have been at least 46 reports of endangered marten being caught during Vermont’s fisher trapping season. And while the VFWD says an average only 2.5 marten are caught in fisher traps annually, in some years such as 2012, as many as 11 marten were killed in legal traps set for fisher. Unlike Wisconsin, where the Wisconsin Trappers Association supports restrictions on trapping in the state’s Marten Restoration Areas, the Vermont Trappers Association supports the legalization of the most common smaller sized body-gripping traps responsible for over 20 years of incidental take in predominantly three small areas of Vermont.
Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department’s proposed furbearer rule change on baited body-gripping traps.
When asked to clarify the reason for wanting to again legalize smaller baited body-gripping traps in Vermont, the VFWD’s general counsel, Hannah Smith stated in a letter, “The proposed change is a technical correction of an unintentional limitation on trap size, the correction is intended to reduce instances of incidental take.” But Vermont is not the only state where incidental take of endangered marten by trappers occurs. According to Wisconsin’s Management and Conservation Plan for American Marten, “Body-grip traps set for fishers appear to be the most common method that leads to incidental take of martens in Wisconsin. For this reason, WDNR and Ojibwe tribes continue to limit trapping opportunities in the MPAs.” The plan further identifies education and training priorities stating, “Trapper education courses should at a minimum discuss marten ecology, current regulations, MPA locations, and alternative trapping techniques to reduce incidental mortalities.”
2026-27 Wisconsin Trapping Regulations (see page 24)
Yet, currently the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board’s Chairman (himself a trapper), Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department and Vermont Trappers Association all support a return to the use of traps most responsible for killing endangered marten in Vermont, despite the incidental takes occurrence in very localized areas where trappers are only required to report marten captures to a warden. According to warden reports obtained through a public records request by VWP, in 2016 one individual fisher trapper caught four marten in just five days of the month-long fisher trapping season in Vermont. He was allowed to continue trapping without any restrictions. In 2012, two fisher trappers were responsible for catching and killing three endangered marten each with three additional marten also killed during the 2012 fisher trapping season.
Email to VFWD furbearer biologist regarding incidental take of marten in 2012.
In a December 28, 2023 Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department press release announcing trapping rule changes as a result of Act 159, the VFWD stated, “The new regulations include a requirement that live trapped animals be killed humanely and establish standards for trap types and use of baits to reduce the risk of catching pets and non-target wildlife.” The then Commissioner of VFWD, Christopher Herrick added, “Vermont’s new trapping regulations will make trapping safer and more humane. They strike a middle ground between concerns raised by both activists and trappers, and are among the most comprehensive trapping regulations in the country.” Yet, by July 2026 absent any biological justification and citing only a hardship caused to trappers, VFWD is recommending again legalizing the very traps most responsible for the incidental take of endangered marten in Vermont. https://www.vtfishandwildlife.com/press-releases/new-regulations-trapping-come-effect-january-1-2024
A Wisconsin marten visiting a WDNR biologists camera trap.
It’s time for the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department, Board and Vermont Trappers Association to follow the lead demonstrated in Wisconsin and restrict the use of baited body-gripping traps in Vermont’s marten recovery areas rather than return them to the landscape where they have already killed dozens of endangered marten. Towards that goal, Vermont Wildlife Patrol is asking Vermonters to contact their county representative of the Fish & Wildlife Board requesting that they vote in support of establishing marten caution areas and the restrictions on the use of baited body-gripping in those recovery areas with a history of incidental take of marten. The successful recovery of the American marten is possible, but not without responsible science based decisions by our Fish & Wildlife Board and Department.
We are asking concerned Vermonters to contact their county representative to the Fish and Wildlife Board to ask that they not allow smaller baited body-gripping traps in known endangered marten areas and to support Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s petition to restrict fisher trapping in towns where marten have already been killed.
Hannah Johnson Caledonia County: ANR.FWBoardCaledonia@vermont.gov
Richard Craig Lamoille County: ANR.FWBoardLamoille@vermont.gov
Since first detected in Vermont in 2004, at least 45 marten have died in body-gripping traps set for fisher
This winter, the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board will ask state legislators to change body-gripping trapping rules to allow smaller meat-baited traps back onto a landscape that have a long-documented history of “incidental take” of endangered American marten. The American marten, sometimes called the pine marten, was extirpated in Vermont and much of New England by the 1900s due to trapping and rampant deforestation. Vermont sits at the southern edge of the marten’s range, with healthier populations in Maine and New York.
“When that rule [furbearer] did get passed, there was an error in the final ruling that we all missed. You can call it a typo, a clerical error, an administrative error. I’ll get into it in more detail another time, but it involves the use of baited body grip on land. There was an error in the size of trap that could be used in that scenario. So I’m going to get this on the agenda for next month and know we can get into it more deeply then, but it’s going to involve opening up the trapping rules to fix this error. It’s been a hardship for trappers for the last two years.”
Chairman Paul Noel, Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board, July 2026 Meeting
In 1989, Vermont launched its own marten reintroduction program in the southern Green Mountains. The reintroduction was at first considered a failure, due in part to competition from other furbearers like the fisher and gray fox, but later surveys have confirmed marten in the same southern mountain reintroduction areas. Since then, other small marten populations are believed to be slowly and naturally recolonizing areas between the Green Mountains and remote regions of the Northeast Kingdom.
Proposed changes for the use of baited body-gripping traps on land.
Both the 2015 and 2025 Vermont Wildlife Action Plans list the American marten as an endangered, high-priority Species of Greatest Conservation Need. Like so much other wildlife, habitat degradation and climate change continue to pose serious threats to marten recovery. Marten prefer high elevations, heavy snow and dense forest with good canopy, but as prime habitat shrinks, marten and fisher ranges overlap, giving the larger fisher an advantage over its smaller cousin.
The first official “in hand” marten recorded in Vermont was in 2004, when a dispersing male was caught and killed in a trap set for fisher in Averill. It wasn’t the first marten killed in a fisher trap; back in 1990, shortly after the reintroduction, one of the released animals was killed in a fisher trap in Shrewsbury. Since 2004, at least 45 more marten have been caught in body-gripping traps, all during Vermont’s December fisher trapping season, all but two were killed. Without a doubt, fisher traps have revealed, and killed, more marten than even the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department previously knew were here. A few have been recorded as roadkill, but since 2004, fisher trapping has remained the number one recognized threat to marten recovery in the Green Mountain State.
The problem is that the endangered marten living in areas with high concentrations of fisher trapping are easily attracted to the same bait and lures used in fisher sets, making any legal fisher trap in known marten habitat, also a marten trap. Yet since 2004, no special requirements have been put in place for body-gripping traps used in fisher sets, or for trappers who catch an endangered marten. There is no requirement to modify triggers to avoid marten, and no requirement to pull or move your traps once you’ve caught an endangered marten. That’s the bigger part of the problem: there have been no restrictions at all on fisher trapping in the two isolated areas where most marten continue to be caught and killed. The only requirement is for trappers to report marten captures to a warden.
According to Vermont Fish and Wildlife public records, as many as 11 individual marten were killed by fisher trappers during the one-month trapping season in 2012. In 2016, one fisher trapper caught and killed four marten in just five days, and was legally allowed to keep trapping in the very same areas. The smaller body-gripping traps the Board now wants to allow (#110, #120, #150 and #160) are the recommended trap for catching marten in states where it is legal to trap marten. Since they were removed from legal baited sets in 2024, reported marten captures dropped. The Fish & Wildlife Board and lawmakers should keep it that way.
“The proposed change is a technical correction of an unintentional limitation on trap size, the correction is intended to reduce instances of incidental take.”
Hannah Smith, General Counsel, Vermont Department of Fish & Wildlife
Warden text messages regarding 2025 take of marten in Ferdinand.
The solution need not be a call to ban trapping, instead we are appealing for trappers to voluntarily take more care in areas where Vermont’s endangered marten are still recovering. This is also an appeal to those opposed to trapping to grow more tolerant of sustainable wildlife management. That is why on October 14, 2026, Vermont Wildlife Patrol presented a petition to the Fish and Wildlife Board asking for restrictions on the use of smaller baited body-gripping traps in marten recovery areas and for protocols to be put into practice for when marten are caught in fisher traps. We are asking that such restrictions remain, until marten recovery goals outlined in the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department’s Wildlife Action Plans are met.
No successful reintroduction of marten, fisher, or other furbearers to places they once lived in Vermont would have been possible without the support of trappers. It only makes sense that they, too, want the fullest, healthiest return of wildlife that not long ago might have been gone forever. A 2022 survey found that 91% of Vermont residents support trapping when it helps return native species to the state. The successful recovery of marten cannot happen without the support of Vermont’s trapping community.
Among the things I love most about Vermont are those quiet winter mornings, staring out my dining room window at the wild world that still surrounds us. I watch black-capped chickadees, juncos and other birds visit our bird feeders. Red squirrels often feed lazily alongside them, leaving me hoping for a “circle of life” moment when one of their native predators drops down to complete the wild food chain. One of those predators is the American marten, which, like so many of Vermont’s endangered species, is struggling to make a full recovery. We can ensure the marten’s return to Vermont. But only if we are willing to work together in the best interests of all Vermonters, both human and animal.
We are asking concerned Vermonters to contact their county representative to the Fish and Wildlife Board to ask that they not allow smaller baited body-gripping traps in known endangered marten areas and to support Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s petition to restrict fisher trapping in towns where marten have already been killed.
Hannah Johnson Caledonia County: ANR.FWBoardCaledonia@vermont.gov
Richard Craig Lamoille County: ANR.FWBoardLamoille@vermont.gov
At the February 18, 2026 Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board’s monthly meeting, a petition was presented by the Vermont Bowhunters Association requesting black bear rule changes that would allow bear baiting by hunters during the Fall season. Another petition was submitted that would establish a youth and novice archery season. The public petitions were part of a larger package of recommendations by the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department (VFW) presented to the Board related to black bear hunting. VFW biologists and Department officials are asking the Board to approve rules that would extend the bear season seven days, increase the bag limit in some areas, allow the revocation of bear dog permits, explore reciprocity non-resident bear hunting rules and prohibit the intentional killing of sows with cubs which is still legal in Vermont. A board vote on the petitions and VFW’s recommendations is expected this Spring.
New Hampshire Bear Bait Supplier
The Fish and Wildlife Board’s 14 members have the authority to reject or amend any recommendations and have not expressed opposition to bear baiting, or any increase in bear hunting opportunities. At the February meeting, while some board members questioned the impact baiting would have on other wildlife, others expressed support saying it would bring money to local economies. When questioned by the board, VFW black bear biologist Jaclyn Comeau said there were concerns that baiting would introduce non-native foods to bears and could contribute to artificially larger litter sizes. She also stated that bait sites increase the likelihood of disease transmission and sarcoptic mange has recently been discovered in Vermont’s bear population. Sarcastic mange is spreading through the Eastern U.S. black bear population and causes intense itching, hair loss, emaciation and death. It is often spread when bears congregate in dens or at “anthropogenic food sources” such as bear baits.
Bear bait currently available in New Hampshire
When asked about the Department’s recommendation on prohibiting the killing of sows with cubs, Comeau said that the vast majority of states in the U.S. that allow black bear hunting also have prohibitions on the killing of sows with cubs. And while the majority of bear hunters recently surveyed said they would never shoot a sow with cubs, 12% were unaware of the Department’s existing recommendation not to kill sows with cubs, as the current hunting rules allow. The Board expressed hesitation in supporting the prohibition, stating that education and “trainings” were preferable to an outright ban on killing sows with cubs, also citing difficulties in enforcing the regulation. Despite an increase in such efforts to discourage the killing of sows with cubs, in recent years bears have been killed in Vermont when cubs were present, resulting in the orphaning and likely starvation or predation of the surviving cubs. Comeau stated such instances could have been prevented with a rule prohibiting the intentional killing of sows with cubs.
Vermont Wildlife Patrol supports the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department’s proposed black bear rule changes, yet we are skeptical that the Board will vote to accept those recommendations, despite them being based in science and in accordance with the state black bear management plan. The Fish and Wildlife Board’s 14 members are governor appointed, and the majority represent the interests of hunters, anglers and trappers. We expect the board to amend the Department’s recommendations and possibly allow baiting and the continued rule allowing the killing of sows with cubs. The current board has repeatedly demonstrated an unwillingness to restrict any hunting opportunity, despite the public and even sportsman’s support for such rule changes.
The next Fish & Wildlife Board meeting is on April 22nd, 2026 at the Dewey Conference Room (Far back of National Life parking lot!) 1 National Life Drive, Montpelier
Watch the February 2026 Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board meeting & petition for bear baiting:
Watch the April 2026 Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board meeting & 2nd petition for bear baiting:
Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department Recommended Changes to Bear Rules…
Vermont Bowhunters Association Petition to Allow Bear Baiting…
Additional petition to change bear hunting rules from April 1, 2026 Fish and Wildlife Board meeting…
The Vermont Fish and Wildlife board has 14 members (one for each county) appointed by the governor and serving a six-year term. Please write to your county representative to let them know you are opposed to bear baiting in Vermont!
Next Scheduled Board Meeting:April 22, 2026 at 5:00 pm, Dewey Conference Room 1 National Life Drive, Montpelier, Vt.
Current Board Members:
Robert Patterson Addison County Lincoln, VT ANR.FWBoardAddison@vermont.gov
Jeffrey Corey Franklin County Fairfax, VT ANR.FWBoardFranklin@vermont.gov
Beth Deimling Grand Isle County Grand Isle, VT ANR.FWBoardGrandIsle@vermont.gov
Richard Craig Lamoille County Morrisville, VT ANR.FWBoardLamoille@vermont.gov
Ryan Kilborn Orange County East Orange, VT ANR.FWBoardOrange@vermont.gov
Neal Hogan Bennington County Bennington, VT ANR.FWBoardBennington@vermont.gov
Paul Noel (Acting Chair) Orleans County Irasburg, VT ANR.FWBoardOrleans@vermont.gov
Martin Van Buren Rutland County Poultney, VT ANR.FWBoardRutland@vermont.gov
Jon Valsangiacomo Washington County Barre, VT ANR.FWBoardWashington@vermont.gov
David Deen Windham County Westminster, VT ANR.FWBoardWindham@vermont.gov
Nicholas Burnham Windsor County Hartland, VT ANR.FWBoardWindsor@vermont.gov
Essex, Caledonia and Chittenden County seats: VACANT
For more information, articles and resources on coexistence with black bears:
“Mange is spread by animals having direct contact with infected animals, or through the use of common areas or objects. Minimize actions that cause bears (and other animals) to congregate. A major activity that encourages congregation of bears is supplemental feeding of wildlife, such as deer, small mammals, turkeys and other birds, which often attracts non-target species, such as bears. Supplemental feeding should be discontinued if there is evidence that bears are being attracted to the area. Even if bears look healthy, it is important to stop feeding because individuals may be infected with the mites and showing subtle or no obvious signs of disease.”
Skunk pelts await processing at a fur buyers warehouse in Illinois.
Vermont Wildlife Patrol filed a report with the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department’s law enforcement division on January 2, 2025 after reading a published report by a Milton trapper admitting and advising other trappers to drown skunks caught in live-traps.
In the November-December 2025 issue of the Vermont Sporting Journal’s column, “Trapline Talk” Randy Barrows writes,
The easiest way to captue (sic) them is with a hav-a-heart trap. Skunks are normally a a real- ly calm critter until you piss in their porridge, then look out. I always carry an old blanket with me to hold between me and the skunk. Cheap insurance. I talk to them softly, cover them up and put them in the truck for a ride to the boat launch and swimming lessons. Shooting them anywhere in the body is met with a discharge. Seldom do they spray while drowning them…”
Randy Barrows also has taught trapper education courses for the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department (VFW) and is a past president of the Vermont Trapper’s Association which inducted him into their Hall of Fame in 2024. On January 1, 2024 new trapping rules went into effect for legal methods of dispatch for trapped animals in Vermont. According to VFW’s website, “Dispatch of a live, trapped furbearer shall immediately be done with a muzzleloader or gun fired at arm’s length; or a bow and arrow, or crossbow; or a carbon dioxide chamber.” As one of VFW’s volunteer trapper education instructors, Barrows is responsible for teaching rule changes to new Vermont trappers.
In another VT Sporting Journal article published in the March-April 2025 issue, Barrows shares his dissatisfaction with the new trapping rules saying, “The fall of 2024 he (another trapper) was unsure if he was going to trap with the fur prices and becoming compliant with all the new BS rules handed down to trappers.”
On January 5, 2025, VFW warden Nathan Lumsden informed Vermont Wildlife Patrol that the investigation had determined that Barrows carried out his skunk trapping activities as a commercial nuisance trapper, outside of the recreational land trapping season that runs from late October to December 31. According to Vermont statute 10 V.S.A. § 4828, such trapping done in defense of property is exempted from the new furbearer regulations and allows for any means of killing of trapped wild animals. Lumsden said the article was a “gross oversight” as the target audience of the Nov.-Dec. Vermont Sporting Journal was recreational, not nuisance trappers. He said Barrows’ report would be corrected.
Nov-Dec 2025 Vermont Sporting Journal
Market demand for skunk tails for the making of Hasidic Jewish hats has driven prices for skunk as high as $80.00 according to Barrows’ report and international fur market reports for 2025. “High fur prices for public trust wildlife should not justify inhumane trapping practices. Drowning is an act of animal cruelty and should not be a legal way to take Vermont wildlife whether in July or November. What good are our new trapping rules if they don’t apply to all trapping?” says Rod Coronado, the investigator reporting the incident to VFW.
What is most disconcerting about Barrows cruel story-telling is that not a single Vermont trapper or reader of the Vermont Sporting Journal raised concern that his instructions were being given at the beginning of Vermont’s regulated trapping season when drowning of trapped animals is prohibited. It speaks to a culture of acceptance for the cruelty that often accompanies our state’s trapping practices. Or is it simply that Vermont’s trappers are either unfamiliar or unwilling to adhere to the new regulations? Vermont Wildlife Patrol is now investigating whether the revised trapping regulations that went into effect in 2024 have been incorporated into Vermont’s trapper education curriculum as mandated by Act 159. The only way to build social tolerance for controversial practices such as trapping, is by ensuring that Vermont’s trappers know and play by the rules established by the Legislature.
Vermont Wildlife Patrol is a 501(c)3 non-profit organization that participated in the rulemaking process that led to Vermont’s new trapping laws, and regularly attends Fish and Wildlife Board meetings to monitor state wildlife management practices.
Vermont’s Adopted Furbearer Species Rules (see 4.16):
No longer will it be legal for bear hunters or others in Vermont to legally sell any internal organs of black bears.
On the closing days of Vermont’s 2024 legislative session, wildlife advocates and the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department worked together to recommend amendment language to an agricultural bill that would end the legal sale of black bear internal organs and paws. Both are the subject of an international illegal trade in black bear parts that is responsible for illegal bear killings in the United States, Canada and other countries. Senate Bill 301 which passed both the House and Senate on May 10, is now headed to Governor Phil Scott’s desk where he is expected to sign the bill into law.
S.301 language on the sale of bear parts.
In September 2023, Vermont Wildlife Patrol asked both the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department and Board to address the continuing illegal trade in black bear parts that Vermont was contributing to through the legal sale of bear parts which is currently allowed in the state. VWP state Director Rod Coronado testified that, “It seems that states that allow the legal trade of bear gall bladders are accommodating the illegal trade by allowing those (illegally taken) gall bladders to come into the state to be sold.” VWP’s position was echoed by the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department’s Chief Warden, Justin Stedman at the May 15, 2024 Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board meeting where he stated there were two active investigations into the illegal sale of bear parts in Vermont and that allowing the legal sale of bear parts was contributing to the sale of illegally taken gall bladders which could be brought into the state and legally sold.
Vermont will still allow the sale of taxidermied bears and bear meat within the state during a regulated season.
Vermont Fish & Wildlife Commissioner Christopher Herrick joined by District Chief Warden Lt. Robert Currier testified to the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Food Resiliency and Forestry that, “We’ve experienced paws being trafficked from the state of Vermont all the way down into Boston and Chinatown, and then we have information that they’re ultimately ending up being shipped to the Asian market overseas. A serving of bear paw soup has been reported to be sold for up to $1,000…just one serving of this soup. You can imagine the amount of money that is being transferred and made off of the natural resources of our state…we are one of the very few states in the country that allows for the sale of these items.” Warden Currier further testified that wildlife traffickers are coming into Vermont to legally buy black bear gall bladders and paws and then illegally ship them out of state where they enter the illicit trade that has decimated black bear populations outside of North America. Vermont’s Deputy Chief Counsel, Michael O’Grady testified that, “Vermont is one of the last (states) to have this provision so it’s kind of a harbor for people who do this kind of activity.”
Illegally taken black bear paws seized by Quebec authorities in 2018. S.301 prohibits the sale of internal organs and bear paws.
While Vermont Fish & Wildlife had recommended and supported the introduction of earlier legislation in the session to end the sale of black bear organs, the original bill did not survive. In the closing days of this year’s session, lobbyist Patti Komline and Bob Galvin were instrumental in getting the bear language added to SB301 with the support of Commissioner Herrick. At the May 15, 2024 Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board meeting in Montpelier, both Vermont Wildlife Patrol and Bob Galvin thanked VFWD’s Commissioner Herrick and the Warden Service for their work on S.301 and expressed support for working together on similar threats to Vermont’s wildlife. Despite a contentious legislative season that saw many wildlife advocates testifying against practices like coyote hunting with dogs and a lack of representation within the Fish & Wildlife Board, Vermont Wildlife Patrol believes the common love for wildlife shared by advocates and the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department and Board will continue to be a foundation for future efforts to protect the wildlife we are all entrusted to protect.
VFWD Commissioner Christopher Herrick & Lt. Robert Currier testifying in support of S.301
Wildlife lobbyist Bob Galvin testifying in support of S.301
House Committee on Agriculture, Food Resiliency and Forestry discuss the sale of bear parts in Vermont.
Documenting coyote baiting and hounding practices near Sutton, Vermont in February 2024.
Despite legislative objections to the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Board’s definition of control of hounds, the first regulated coyote hunting season with dogs ran from late January to the end of March 2024. Last fall, the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department (VFW) testified to the Legislative Committee on Administrative Rules (LCAR) that more than the allotted 100 permits may be required in the state’s first regulated season of the controversial sport. Yet only forty-one permits were issued. Many licensed hounders reported not hunting during the season, while nine are in violation of the new rules for not submitting a mandatory take report by April 2, 2024. In a May 1st email VFW staff stated, “The wardens are actively following up with permit holders who have not complied with the report requirement.”
Total number of coyote dog permits issued in January 2024.
The statement comes just a week after VFW Commissioner Christopher Herrick testified to House legislators that Senate Bill 258, which would prohibit coyote baiting and hunting with dogs was unnecessary because the recently concluded season resulted in “…no landowner conflicts” Herrick did not comment on any suspected violations during the abbreviated season which started in January 2024 rather than December 2023 because of the objections filed by LCAR last year. A public records request by Vermont Wildlife Patrol revealed that while 41 permits were issued in person by VFW wardens, as of May 1st only 28 of the mandatory required reports had been returned to VFW as required by the new rules.
Mandatory reporting form that 9 of the 41 permitted hounders have not returned as of May 1st, 2024.
Wallingford, Vermont coyote hounder Terence Wilbur shared these photos on his Facebook page in 2022.
A total of 55 coyotes were reportedly killed by the 28 hound hunters reporting. While most hunters took only a few coyotes during the season, one East Fairfield licensed hounder reported killing 15 coyotes on nine separate hunts between February 3rd and March 23, 2024. This information comes as S.258 remains in the House Committee on Environment and Energy where it is awaiting a vote before the legislative session ends in mid-May.
Coyotes harvested by licensed hounder during 2024 season.
Vermont Wildlife Patrol is asking Vermonters to contact their House representatives and tell them you support a YES vote on S.258 before the season for coyote hunting dog training season begins on June 1st. 20% of the licensed hunters in the first regulated season failing to report their kills is reason enough to ban this controversial practice that is obviously impossible to regulate.
From the February 21, 2024 Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board meeting in Montpelier, Vermont.
All last week, the Vermont Senate Committee on Natural Resources and Energy heard testimony on Senate Bill 258, an act related to the management of fish and wildlife. The bill includes provisions that would end coyote baiting and hunting with dogs, strengthen the state’s new trapping regulations by requiring all traps to be set at least fifty feet from trails and other places people are expected to recreate. Most importantly for all future wildlife policy decisions, S.258 would also change the rule making authority of the Fish and Wildlife Board and the way its members are appointed. It would also require any member to be knowledgeable and informed with the best science on wildlife issues and required to learn about wildlife conflict resolution and the impact of climate change on our wildlife.
Vermont Wildlife Patrol was just one of many voices speaking from the experience of feeling unheard by the current board. I provided the Senate Committee with links to nine different board meetings where I provided comment on issues before the board. On February 21, 2024 at the board’s monthly meeting, I testified that all of Vermont’s wildlife was not abundant and flourishing, in response to the Commissioner of Fish and Wildlife’s testimony earlier that day to the Senate Committee that it was. I cited lynx, eastern cougar, gray wolf, caribou, marten and fisher as native Vermont species that have yet to fully recover in the state. Fisher now being threatened by rodenticide poisoning in addition to the continued loss of habitat and a statewide no bag limit trapping season.
Link to Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s and other citizen’s testimony on S.258:
Testimony of Addison County resident to Senate Committee on Natural Resourcesand Energy on February 22, 2024.
Ironically, after my public comments were received the board heard a report on the proposed 2024 waterfowl hunting season that included an update on eastern mallard populations which have declined 38% percent since 1998. The decrease in breeding pairs of Vermont mallards led to a reduction in the bag limit from four to two birds a day for three years. Various factors are suspectedly responsible for the decline, hybridization with game farm raised ducks, habitat fragmentation, increased hay-cutting in nesting areas and hunting are possibly all to blame for the alarming reduction in this iconic species.
At the February board meeting, I also called out the acting chair and board representative from Orange County, Michael Bancroft for not having approached Vermont Wildlife Patrol to discuss any of the issues that I’ve brought up at board meetings. I said that the lack of other people from Orange County attending board members begged the question, who was he listening too if not my own voice? At the break, Bancroft approached me to humbly thank me for calling him out and acknowledged that he had spoken to no other constituents from Orange County and indeed it was time for a discussion. No Vermonter should have to wait a year for their voices to be heard by any representative.
Testimony of West Glover resident to Senate Committee on Natural Resourcesand Energy on February 22, 2024.
At the heart of S.258 is a legislative desire to remedy the fact that many Vermonters who do not hunt, trap or fish do not feel represented or heard by the current board, who predominantly are hunters and trappers appointed by Governor Phil Scott. In the last year of attending board meetings, petitions presented by wildlife advocates are routinely denied while petitions that increase hunting and trapping opportunities are readily approved. S.258 would limit the number of board members the governor could appoint while preventing any majority of members from any particular stakeholder group, such as exists with the current board.
Two six-year board terms expire in February 2024, for Essex and Grand Isle Counties.
We encourage all Vermonters to access the hours of testimony given for and against S.258 to better make your own informed decision on whether you believe a new fish and wildlife board is warranted. Perhaps no better opportunity exists for Gov. Phil Scott to prove that the current board demographic is truly representative of Vermont, thank with his soon appointment of two new board members for Essex and Grand Isle Counties. Both board terms expire at the end of February 2024. Vermont Wildlife Patrol challenges the governor to be fair and impartial in his appointment of new Fish and Wildlife Board members.
Vermont Wolf Patrol is partnering with For Love of All Things (FLOAT.org) to offer these logo t-shirts, tank tops and hoodies to help us raise funds for our current citizen monitoring of coyote hound hunting practices in Vermont, in support of Senate Bill 258, which would end the practice once and for all. $8 from every purchase goes towards our winter field campaign which began in January 2024 when the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department issued 36 permits to hound hunters despite our legislature’s legal opinion that a moratorium was still in place.
Here’s a video of a recent encounter with coyote hound hunters at the Calendar Brook Wildlife Management Area near Sutton, Vermont. These hunters were operating off of a bait pile that was dumped to attract coyotes that could then be tracked by hunting hounds. S.258 would also ban the use of bait to hunt coyotes and bring much needed reform to the archaic Fish & Wildlife Board.
Stay tuned for more updates as the Vermont Senate Committee on Natural Resources and Energy receives testimony on this important bill this week. And if you are a Vermonter, please contact your elected state officials and let them know you support Senate Bill 258!
Find your legislator:
legislature.vermont.gov
This Western coyote, with a luxurious fur coat, poses in snow and grass, on a sunny day.
On the heels of disagreements between legislators and the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department and Board (VFW) over control of hunting hounds, the Chair of the Senate Committee on Natural Resources and Energy has introduced S.258 which would restructure the Fish & Wildlife Board and prohibit the hunting of coyotes with dogs. On December 14, 2023 the Legislative Committee on Administrative Rules (LCAR) filed objections to VFW’s new coyote hunting with dogs rules arguing that the regulations failed to meet the legislative mandate of Act 165. LCAR’s objections were centered on the inability of hound hunters to recall loose dogs, having recommended that the animals be kept within sight and voice control. VFW has argued that GPS tone and shock collars are effective at recalling dogs when they stray onto posted property.
S.258 As Introduced on January 12, 2024
Members of the Fish & Wildlife Board and legal counsel for VFW, Catherine Gjessing have all called LCAR’s recommendations a “defecto ban” on coyote hunting with dogs, stating it is impossible to keep coyote hounds within sight during a hunt. LCAR voted to approve most of the new coyote hunting and trapping rules in November 2023, but because VFW was unwilling to compromise on the control of loose dogs and some trapping issues, LCAR filed four objections which leaves VFW open to possible litigation. Because of LCAR’s objections, the burden of proof would be on VFW to prove that the new rules meet legislative intent.
Back in January 2022, the Vermont Senate Committee on Natural Resources and Energy first introduced S.281 which quite simply proposed to prohibit the pursuit of coyote with the aid of dogs, either for the training of dogs or for the taking of coyote. Senator Christopher Bray, the Chair of the committee and a member of LCAR was one of the legislators who reached a compromise with the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Department over concerns about control of loose dogs. But when the final rules were written, VFW and the Board had agreed that GPS tone and shock collars were adequate as a control method.
Vermont Wildlife Patrol’s February 2022 investigation of coyote hunting with hounds in Addison County, Vermont.
A much more timely disagreement between both members of LCAR and the Senate Committee on Natural Resources and Energy is over whether the moratorium on coyote hunting with dogs that resulted from the passage of S.281 in May 2022 is still in effect. Following the filing of objections, LCAR wrote to VFW stating:
“The five members of LCAR who voted to file the fourth objection in certified form are of the opinion that the fourth objection being filed in certified form shifts the burden of proof to the Fish and Wildlife Board in any action for judicial review or for enforcement of the rule related to Secs. 3.6 and 4.20, see 3 V.S.A. § 842(c)(2), and should be interpreted as evidence that the current moratorium on pursuing coyote with the aid of dogs is not lifted upon the effective date of the November 30, 2023, Rule, if adopted, because Secs. 3.6 and 4.20 of the November 30, 2023, Rule do not meet the minimum requirements of the rules required by Sec. 3 of Act 165, specifically Sec. 3(b)(4), and therefore the triggering event for the repeal of the moratorium in Act 165, Sec. 2(b) has not been met. This opinion is consistent with the intent of the General Assembly that the moratorium on pursuing coyote with aid of dogs remain in place until the effective date of a Fish and Wildlife Board rule that meets the minimum requirements of Act 165, Sec. 3, of which the November 30, 2023, Rule does not.“
Addison County, Vermont hound hunters
Less than a week after receiving the above letter from LCAR regarding the moratorium, on December 18, 2023 VFW issued a press release stating that the new coyote rules were now in effect and permit applications for coyote hunting with dogs were now available until January 15th when a lottery would be held if applications exceeded the 100 available permits. As of January 9th, only 35 applications had been received. No coyote hunting with dogs is allowed until permits are received according to VFW.
Link to Vermont Fish & Wildlife’s Hunting Coyotes with Dogs page:
On January 12, 2024 Senator Bray sponsored and introduced S.258 to change the consumptive user focused Fish & Wildlife Board’s appointment process and to make the board advisory only. The bill would also prohibit hunting coyotes with dogs. During the December 2023 LCAR hearings, Bray indicated to constituents that it was his hope that the moratorium on coyote hunting with dogs would remain in effect until S.258 could be passed this legislative session.
Meanwhile, with permits likely to be issued as soon as January 16th, hound hunters are likely to break the moratorium on hunting coyotes with dogs when the next snow falls providing optimum hunting conditions for finding fresh coyote tracks. Vermont Wildlife Patrol will be monitoring coyote hunting with dogs to document whether hunters are indeed able to recall loose dogs as the new rules require.